hey guys so in this CashNews.co we’re going through the math on whether it’s better to pay off your mortgage early or invest usually if you are trying to answer this question it means that you have extra money left over after you pay all of your bills for the month and now
you’re just trying to optimize the remaining dollars that you have so first off I just want to say if that is you congratulations because most people are not in this situation as the gross personal Savings rate in America is around 3.6% and many people are living paycheck to
paycheck now in order to figure out what is best for you it’s going to depend on a lot factors but the biggest factor is your mortgage interest rate we’re first going to talk about how the mortgage payment is broken down because understanding how it works is absolutely key in figuring
out what’s right for you then once we understand that we can actually answer what makes the most sense mathematically and financially and then in addition I’ll share some strategies to help you pay off your home early if that’s what you’re interested in and other intangibles
to consider when it comes to paying off the mortgage early or investing all right so at a really basic level when you get a mortgage you’re buying a home with borrowed money from your Bank you must then pay back the sum that you borrowed with interest over time because hey that’s how
Banks make money so let’s say you borrow $400,000 to buy a house and you get this standard 30-year fixed rate mortgage the bank will make it really easy for you and break down how much you need to pay them back on a monthly basis for the next 30 Years or 360 payments so each monthly payment
is broken down into two components and understanding this is really vital in answering this whole question that we have today the first component is you borrowed a large sum of money so you need to pay that thatb back over the 30 years and this is called the principal the second part of the payment
is the interest on the total sum of the money that you borrowed so interest on whatever remaining balance you haven’t paid off yet so on a $400,000 Loan over 30 years at a 7% interest rate your interest payment is always going to be represented as the following it’s
your balance remaining times the interest rate or 7% divided by 12 months and that is your monthly payment of Interest so in the first month of your $400,000 mortgage your payment is going to be roughly 26 $60 but here’s the really fascinating or messed up part depending on how you view
Finance a mortgage follows what’s called an amortization schedule which is just a fancy table that details each monthly payment on a Loan in month one
of your payment your 2660 payment is broken up into the two components that we talked about earlier but here’s the crazy thing $2,333 of it goes towards interest and only $327 of your payment goes towards the total amount that you actually owe for the house and this is actually how mortgages
work the banks frontload all the interest payments because they need to get paid first but by doing so you don’t really ever make a dent in the principal balance AKA how much you owe until way later in the life of the Loan and this becomes problematic because you’re
being charged interest on the remaining balance that you owe and if you’re never making a dent in the principle it can seem kind of hopeless it’s so shocking in fact that in the first 20 years out of a 30-year fix rate mortgage your interest payments actually still exceed the amount
that you pay on the principal on Every Single monthly payment said differently that means in the first 20 years or 240 payments the majority of your payments are still going towards the bank and not towards paying back your Loan in fact if we take a look at the yearly amortization
schedule right here you can see at the end of year 20 you will still owe $229,200 on your house so you’re 66% through the mortgage already in terms of time elapsed but you’ve only paid off 42.75 per of the sum that you originally borrowed talk about disproportional and often times with
mortgages the amount of interest that you pay could easily be equal equal to or more than the amount that you actually borrowed if you borrowed $400,000 for 30 years at an interest rate of 7% the total amount of interest that you pay is actually $558,500 th000 in the first place that brings the
total amount that you paid for this Loan to be 958k now if your interest rate were 5% you would have paid $373,000 in interest over the life of the Loan and if your interest rate was 3% you will pay $27,000 $19 over the life of the Loan all pretty
crazy so this is pretty eye opening that means if we can reduce our principal balance as soon as we can we can actually not only pay off our mortgage faster we can reduce the total amount of interest that we pay saving us a ton of money in the long run all right hopefully you’re still with me
the next part is actually very interesting so if you’re enjoying this so far make sure to subscribe to the channel it’s completely free and only takes .1 seconds or less so let’s actually examine now what Stock Market returns look like and actually whether or not
it makes sense to pay off your mortgage early or invest now when it comes to investing quote the S&P 500’s average annualized return since adopting 500 stocks into the index in 1957 is around 10.26% so you can reasonably expect to get around a 10% return in the Stock
Market historically and after considering Taxes a good ballpark figure that I think we could probably get is around 7 to 8% when it comes to the interest rate on your mortgage Let’s Pretend the interest rate is say let’s say 3% if you make extra payments
towards your mortgage then you’re basically going to be earning 3% on your money in this situation so let’s say for example you got your mortgage back in 2021 when the mortgages were around let’s say 2.98% you mathematically are going to be a lot better off investing instead of
paying off your mortgage and that’s simply due to the fact that you are earning 3% by making extra payments on your mortgage but if you took extra dollars and invested it you were averaging 10% per year or roughly 7 to 8% after tax which is definitely higher than your 3% so let’s
examine how asset classes have been performing over the last 10 years and we can see the annualized returns here of different asset classes like large cap growth stocks large cap value stocks small caps International stocks cash and Etc you can feel free to pause the CashNews.co here if you’d
like to see how certain asset classes have performed over the past 10 years but what I really want to show you is this summary table of all the returns of the S&P 500 from 1928 we can see that since 2009 most years have returned positively and the average year since 2009 returns way higher than
let’s say 3% we should also note though that when you are investing there are going to be a couple of losing years that you might experience for example in 2018 and 2022 so my takeaway as of right now at this point in the CashNews.co is that if you have a low interest rate let’s say
2.5% 3% or maybe even up to 5% on your mortgage it’s always going to make more financial sense to invest than to pay off your mortgage early when the Interest Rates get to say 6 or 7% like they have been most recently the decision becomes a lot closer some people are going to
favor paying off the mortgage early not due to financial benefits but more intangible benefits like peace of mind let’s pretend you have a 6% interest rate on your mortgage now with a 6% interest rate you’re effectively getting a risk-free and tax-free 6% rate of return on any extra
dollars that you pay off your mortgage early with while 6% is not impossible to achieve in the Stock Market it may be risky to achieve in the Stock Market because as we showed earlier not every year is going to return positively there’s always going to be
some inherent risk whenever you take your money and invest it into something in addition there is an intangible benefit of being able to get peace of mind and a risk-free rate of return of 6% on your money that you may choose to actually pay off your mortgage early instead of investing it now there
is one more component and variable that we need to discuss here that I haven’t actually accounted for but it is absolutely Paramount and very important to this whole equation which is how many years do you have left on your mortgage and how many years do you have left to invest generally
speaking the more time you have left on your mortgage the greater the potential benefit from investing is for that same time period so so assuming both are equal and that’s because the power of compounding so if you’re able to use an extra $500 per month for example and let’s say
we actually invest it instead of paying off or mortgage an extra $500 a month for 25 years and an 8% interest rate which is the average Stock Market returns will actually Yield you over $473,000 paying off an extra $500 per month for 25 years towards your mortgage
will save you $188,000 in interest over the life of the Loan now why is this you’ll notice that in both of these screenshots I used 8% for both the investing rate of return as well as the mortgage interest rate why is it that if your interest rate on your mortgage is 8% and
your investing rate is 8% that your results are going to be wildly different well that all has to do with the amortization schedule we are now trying to compare the amortization of the mortgage to just the compounded growth of the Investments which by Nature we really can’t
compare the two your extra payments in the mortgage are going to reduce the principal faster and your Savings are in the form of reduced interest over time versus in the investing scenario you are taking your money and compounding the returns immediately which in turn grows your
end balance exponentially we’re also considering a 25-year time Horizon in this example which not everyone watching this CashNews.co has perhaps you have 5 years left on your mortgage 10 years or say 15 years at that point the investing versus paying off debate becomes a lot closer in terms
of the math and you need to run the numbers yourself but so far if you want my two general rules of thumb so far in this CashNews.co it is number one the lower your interest rate on your mortgage the better it probably is to invest and and number two the longer your time Horizon the better it is
probably to invest but both of these general rules of thumb are coming from the financial and mathematical Viewpoint and paying off a home is not exactly always a financial decision the freedom you might get when you don’t have to make a mortgage payment every month might be worth more to you
than anything money could buy so with that being said how do you go about paying off your mortgage faster without breaking the bank entirely I’m going to run you through three different strategies which all have the same common theme which is that you actually have to apply extra payments
towards the uh principal balance of your mortgage but however these strategies are easier to mentally handle and let’s actually use calculator. Net’s mortgage payoff calculator to really help us illustrate these the first strategy involves making bi-weekly payments so if your mortgage
payment is 2660 a month like in our example divide that monthly payment into two and make that payment every 2 weeks so in this case 2660 divide by 2 is $1,330 by doing so every 2 weeks you are actually making 26 bi-weekly payments or 13 monthly total payments a year that means over the course of
the Loan you are making one extra payment towards the principal every single year now please note though whenever you do this you must call your bank and let them know to apply any extra payments beyond the normal monthly interest you owe to go towards the principal balance and not
the future interest payments and that’s how you’re actually going to pay off your mortgage faster so let’s say on this $400,000 mortgage at a 7% interest rate making bi-weekly payments actually allows you to pay off the mortgage the entire Mortgage in 23 years and 11 months saving
you 6 years and 1 month of payments and over $134,000 in interest so I think this is a bit of a mental hack but if you’re able to afford this from the get-go of your mortgage you could see yourself saving a ton of money throughout the course of the Loan all right the next
strategy just involves paying down an extra 00 or $200 per month if you’re able to say pay an extra $200 per month on this Mortgage in particular you’ll still save roughly 6 years of payments and $126,000 in interest both of these first two strategies work much better when interest rate
is say 6 to 7 or even 8% but when the interest rate is a lot lower such as a 2.5 or 3% interest rate the Savings are just going to be a little bit smaller all right and the last strategy that I have for you guys here is that whenever you guys get a tax refund perhaps you get a
bonus check or a winfall of cash you can apply that onetime payment to the principal balance you can see here that if we got a windfall of cash of around $112,500 one time and one time only and we put it towards that principal balance the Loan will be paid off in 201 years and 2
months AKA 2 years and 10 months earlier and we saved $78,900 in interest on a 30-year Loan the more time you have left on the mortgage the more of these principles of paying off your mortgage early will save you more money in the long run I hope this illustrates to you the power
of making extra payments towards paying off your mortgage which should in turn give you powerful and tangible benefits such as the following first I think you get increased peace of mind not having a mortgage payment is almost like a weight lifted off your shoulders second not having a monthly
payment means that you free up that money for other activities such as investing third it lowers your Debt to Income ratio which could in turn increase your Credit score in case you want to borrow more money for something else I hope you
don’t but in case you want to and lastly this home could be ready for you for retirement and it could be an asset that you pass down to your kids but if your kids are really greedy and you really hate them and you want to send them off to boarding school then you don’t have to either
all right but what would you do what are you going to do let me know in the comments I would love to hear from you if you’re interested in how much of a house you can afford and if your current home is within good Budgeting principles check out this CashNews.co right here and
also make sure to subscribe to this channel it’s free once again I’ll see you guys in that CashNews.co or a next one on my channel thank you for being here all right peace
CashNews, your go-to portal for financial news and insights.
What's your current mortgage rate and are you considering paying off your mortgage early or investing? PS: Be aware of the spam/scam comments in the below comment section. I just purged a bunch, but there will inevitably be more that pop up. If theres ever a comment with a lot of likes but they're referring you to some random person's name and promises of returns…its a scam.
If you have the money to do either, you aren’t watching a YouTube video for financial advise
I'd like to point out that the way mortgage payments are described in this video inst how it works everywhere. Sounds pretty predatory to be honest and is unfairly working in the banks favor.
For instance in the country I live you cannot get a 30 year fixed loan and instead you decide to fix for up to 5 years at a time. After that period you can decide to fix again based on the variable rate and what the banks are offering. There is also no front loading of interest repayments.
I have never heard anyone say " wow, I really wish I didn't pay off my mortgage.." I think paying off mortgage was the smartest decision my wife and I did 👍
Good video!
Other factors to consider…
If you itemize deductions on your tax return, you can deduct the mortgage interest. For MFJ folks making "Over $89,450 but not over $190,750", that's deducting income from your 22% tax bracket. In other words, every $100 you spend on mortgage interest saves on $22 on April 15. That, of course, reduces the benefits of paying off your mortgage ahead of time, further lending to the mathematical sensibility of investing and leaving your mortgage as is.
Another factor… the screenshot at 7:53 is not the whole picture. By paying off your mortgage earlier, you're saving money, right? But what are you DOING with the money you save? If you reinvest it at the stock market at 8%, what would the numbers show then? (If you included reinvestment rate, what would the end result/MIRR be?) That may lend some credit to paying off your mortgage early.
All in all, I think you'd need a pretty nifty spreadsheet! 🙂
Good video, Im from Australia and found this vid helpful. I took out my mortgage in 2014 for 450k and currently our balance is 40k, the property is valued at around 700k currently. Our loan payments are very low at this balance as the loan still has another 20 years. I’ve started putting money into a share portfolio to diversify a bit over the past year. So far the shares have had a pretty good year. I earn around 125k and wife around 90kv(no kids), i suspect if all goes well we should pay off our home in 2025 but we would like to pickup an investment property at some stage
My partner and I are both 30, have a mortgage of $529k at 6.75% and are not sure what to do. I feel like we're right in the middle and can't decide. I was hoping to refinance but these rates are not coming down as quick as I had hoped.
Great strategy
There is no price on peace of mind. Pay off your mortgage. Take out all of the risk. Once your home is paid for, you'll never have to worry about where you will live, especially if you have a family. Breadwinners, do your family a solid and pay off the house. God forbid something happens to you, make sure to set up your families and not have them worry about where they will live. Also have a term-life policy just in case too. It's a no brainer.
LOL financial “professionals” don’t make fees if you pay down your debt. Don’t ever listen to them. There have been 10+ years of flat to down periods in the stock market. Average 10% return is such a ridiculous and biased assumption because it assumes you own stocks for like 100 years. The actual comparison should be to a similar term treasury bill.
The rule of thumb is max out your 401k then pay down mortgage. It’s always better to pay down mortgage instead of taxed investments.
Maintaining the payment amount when / if interest rates are reduced is a good way to overpay without feeling like its costing you anything
Recently had solar installed on my home freeing up my electric bill. Looking to take those savings and apply them monthly for ~$250 extra payments.
Banks don’t front-load the interest. You are just paying interest each year based on the outstanding balance. You define the rate at which you pay down your principal based on the mortgage duration. It’s not correct to imply banks are screwing you by front-loading. It’s straight interest on money borrowed.
My issue with making extra mortgage payments is that the bank will still foreclose on your house if you miss too many payments. You’re more protected from defaulting on your loan if you put the money in a brokerage account because you can still keep making payments, even if you lose your job.
I can't believe this is legal
The bi weekly payment methed was very popular in the 80s when morgage interest rates where somewhere near 20%. That is also when banks started to apply any extra payments to the next months interest to stop people from paying off their loans early.
Stop it. You need to justify my Amazon purchases to my wife.
I wish my mortgage was just $2660
Hey Humphrey, I think you forgot to mention the $150,000 of principal paydown when comparing the interest savings to the total stock market portfolio future value. This way would compare the two scenarios more accurately!
Not to mention that, depending on where you're putting the savings, that money can disappear through a lot of different life circumstances….divorce, major medical, taxes, law suites, etc.. Though money in your home isn't untouchable, if it's your primary residence, it's far more difficult for people to get to.
I’m 35 and I have about $250k liquid in savings which I plan to put towards becoming a homeowner but based on the current high prices on real estate, do you suggest I hold from buying or do stocks for now?
Pay off your house and eliminate your debt so that every dollar that you earn can be used to enjoy life.
Money doesn’t go with you to the grave YOLO
Investing keeps cash on hand which allows you the flexibility to capitalize on any abnormal financial opportunities that may arise.
I am at a 2.7% and pretty much will never get rid of this loan. Ill buy another house and rent this one out first.
Success depends on the actions or steps you take to achieve it. Building wealth involves developing good habits like regularly putting money away in intervals for solid investments. Financial management is a crucial topic that most tend to shy away from, and ends up haunting them in the near future.., I pray that anyone who reads this will be successful in life!!
This should be part of basic high school education. People not understanding this well is a complete failure of the education system.
I’m in the unique situation that whenever I pay off my mortgage I can choose to lower the monthly amount. And this means I can exponentially pay off more every month which dramatically changes the calculation in my case. If you have this option, I would advise to choose it rather than shortening your mortgage length since inflation will help towards the end anyway 😊
Thanks for the insights – Given that the S&P 500 yields ~ 10% return before taxes, at what point of interest rate (%) would you personally think would be a good idea to pay down the mortgage instead of investing? Let's assume we're looking at a 20 year horizon.
From paying for day care and college, to managing mortgage payments. I'm approaching retirement yet inflation is getting worse and recession is biting harder by the day. How can I generate more income to retire with at least $3m for long term care? I have about 750k in savings.