asalam alaykum and welcome back to the channel today we are having very interesting topics often requested it’s about Islamic banking how do Islamic Banks or Islamic financial institutions make money so make yourself a nice cup of coffee I’m here at the cafe enjoying my coffee
so you make your tea coffee whatever you like and let let’s get into this episode so just before I posted the last YouTube CashNews.co my daughter asked me but how do Islamic Banks actually make money how do they do things differently from conventional so let’s start with a simple
principle when it comes to the Islamic Finance I’ll give you a story that will illustrate this point and then I will show you how if you understand this story you will understand
basically everything or 90% of what’s happening so the story go something like this so one day father and a son decided to go for a picnic to nice beautiful mountain and enjoy their time with the friends but as they arrived to the location it started to rain they they would really have a time
to unpack and prepare themselves so the rain got everything wet and at that same time group of their friends that they were expecting arrived now as it is a custom you normally prepare some tea or coffee for your friends uh but now everything was wet you couldn’t make uh fire so a father said
to his son he says my dear boy why don’t you figure out some way to make us a fire so we can cook some tea son thought about it he wanted to please his father do something that is good make his father proud so he went and looked around but he couldn’t find anything that was dry then he
remembered his father has got a metal box in the tent in a in in a in another box and inside that metal box there is some money and what he knows about the money is made from paper and it is in Secure location so it is dry it in fact is the only thing that is dry around them so he gathered the pile
of that money he sets it on fire and soon after that he prepares the tea now as he was bringing the tea to the father and his friends father was very happy he was very proud of his son and he said to his guest you see how clever my boy is there is nothing dry around us yet he was able to cook us
tea so the question here often becomes what will father do and how he is going to react once he learn the way his son prepare the tea it’s obvious father will not be pleased now the question for you is is it is it problem beer tea or the outcome or the way we have arrived at that outcome so
if we link this to the everyday business economy everybody wants to make money Profit have things that that they want but where is the challenge challenge is how do we get there so specifically in this story what was the problem the problem here was not just that the sun
didn’t understand the value of money it’s that’s not the essence of the problem that’s a mistake but the essence of the problem was that he used the money for the purpose that money was not supposed to be used as money as a medium of exchange something that help us bying
sell has a different purpose now you could use it for burning it and creating the fire but that’s not what money is meant to do what is meant to burn and create a fire is a wood charcoal things of that nature so to use money properly in this case you should go to the store and buy things and
then use those things for their intended purposes so what Islam wants to see is that money performs a function to help facilitate the trade buying and selling and all the other FS they do their function in society now when it comes to the banking the what we are doing with the money these days is
basically we are using money as a commodity for sale so we take money and then we give money to someone and then we expect more money this is the principle where two system conventional and Islam basically diverge in Islam if you want to make money money must become some asset some commodity
something of value that has some benefit or value in itself any that is sold or leased or something is done that is useful to generate Profit for the customer so the idea here is that whenever you buy and sell Commodities you are linking yourself with the productive purposes with
the real Assets whenever you are trading money for money you are basically unlinking yourself from the real economy you are letting Financial economy grow one system then incentivizes work and production in a real economy where other system will basically incentivize the growth of
money and this is how this financial or synthetic economy starts to grow so when it comes to the bank then Islamic Bank and conventional bank would differ in the way that they none;">Finance things so conventional Bank mostly would sell you basically money they would give you money let’s say we’re talking about home Loan you get some money as a Loan to buy by house so the house is not a subject matter of a
contract it’s a collateral so you’re getting money and then you’re returning more money I understand on simple level one could think just in terms of well I’m getting the uh home to buy and I’m just returning the same money like anybody else but it’s it’s a
matter of a principle where in Islamic Bank what you would see is that the bank should actually buy that house and then sell or lease house to you what is confusing a lot of people is that they say but I thought this is interest free yes interest free doesn’t mean Profit free
now Profit a lot of people confuse this part when we say interest is prohibited interest is Profit as well and business Profit is Profit as well so what does interest mean in terms of illegitimate Profit is that it
is result of a transaction where Islam doesn’t want to see gain Profit which is from lending money all this to say basically that Islamic Bank will need to have some skin in the game they will need to connect themselves with the real economy a real asset when they are getting
benefit from their money or from their business where the other bank would basically just move the money around so so on the basic level that might look the same outcome might look the same both might get the same benefit from this at the end of the day but once we start building now this system
what do we get we start incentivizing this movement of money for Profit and then this starts filtering in everything we want to go for Holiday we want to just spend money for whatever we start just we go into the Loaning of money we want to run a business we want
an investment it’s not structured anymore more as something that is connected with the real life real a real business a real investment we start structuring everything just to be money for money so over time investors Banks anybody who has a Capital is now unlink from the
real activities their Profit and everything doesn’t come from real life it comes from just movement of money that generates the Profit so this Starts Now building whole different economy you see in this economy people become more risk averse they’re
looking for easy opportunity to make money they’re starting get to this secure way where no matter they would look at no matter what happened with these businesses they are expecting the same return they don’t want to risk anything they don’t want to be rewarded from the fruits of
the work or a business or anything real they just want to be rewarded from giving you that money so that basically puts people at almost two opposing ends on the other hand and when it comes to Islamic Bank what starts happening is because the bank is now linked with the real life you cannot have
that compounding effect you cannot have that unnatural growth because you are tattered to the real things to the real economy so we cannot have this expansion of the Credit bubble derivatives Financial products leverage that hugely increases this fictional economy Financial economy
that is is not anymore linked with anything now as a banker once you start thinking at a higher level you are increasing this Debt and growing Debt you are incentivizing creation of the Debt and speed by which Debt starts
accumulate everything become opportunity to create more Debt and then you start slicing and selling the Debt and creating more derivatives and betting on thatt and taking Insurance and then you start suddenly seeing what are we creating you are
creating economy where everybody wants to get on the band wagon of creating the Deb and so nobody can compete with that so even the real business start benchmarking themselves against somebody who is making money easy way so why would I grow food or make bread or do real things where I can also
participate in this creation of the death with no links with the real economy so soon your products that you are eating become fake because nobody can compete with this synthetic way of making money so that they would rather make fake products and just sell you something looks real for some
Profit because they have to also return their investors similar return like the people who are doing nothing and getting money more and more money as Return of the growth of this financial economy so this whole thing incentivize the synthetic way of making money and that start
messing up with the real economy because if you want in that economy to grow real food for example do the real hard work expect real return from the ground from the you have a wholesome product it’s not rewarded anymore because nobody now wants to wait be slow be rewarded from the real fruits
of their labor so labor is diminished in terms of how we value labor hard work what what what should be rewarded what is rewarded is these Bankers to more clever ways they can spin money around more clever derivatives they can make out of it and so we end up in a situation like we had in global
financial crisis where suddenly had this whole economy started collapsing because there was no reality into it and who bails the burden average people they get flood of these Loans opportunities they don’t even know what’s happening anymore and the governments take it
further they start doing the same thing and so to cover this they they start printing more money and so we had this whole system where money is printed Financial economy is growing Profits needs to come on on the back of even more financial productss that are being created and so
you now have a situation where even the politicians the way they manage this economy monetary policies is simply by moving Interest Rates up and down and these career politicians just like these Bankers they don’t have any other tool that they know of how to engage anymore in
real things only thing they know is charge more for money or less for money and just take from you Central Bank just increase Interest Rates reach more into your pocket extracts more money for you and they say we’re managing Inflation is spit so you see from
the little principle once you disconnect yourself from the real economy the system becomes completely different it become brutal it become war against the people because the way starts crumbling down incentivizing and moving money it’s a type of modern day slavery that’s why you see
people Shackled with the Debt Credit cards Loans mortgages this inflates price of everything your normal house that you to be uh you know $200,000 will become five times more because of this whole gain nothing is connected with the real economy
everything is built and is leeching from that real economy so what Islam wants to see Islam wants to return us to the Natural State where your Profit comes from hard work providing the benefit from linking yourself with the risk and reward associating with actually liability owning
the asset engaging into business providing some benefit it’s a different world view and that world view is paired with a lot of other layers in between how you are consuming what are your aspirations sense of gratitude content not just jumping like what we see Capitalism
materialism just in incentivizing just owning more and more and more nobody wants what they have everybody wants the latest the new and there is that cycle of materialism people get caught up because easy Debt everything become a flood of ways to consume more
Credit cards buy now pay later all of these schemes are just making you spend more and more and more and you are promised just like our grandfather Adam in Paradise if you just get one more purchase if you just do this you’ll be happy like Angels Immortal this is the promise
of this financialized secular materialistic worldview that wants us to consume because it’s easy to structure these transactions for the banks and the providers that’s why I believe returning us to the original principle Timeless principle seeking out wisdom of God in these things can
reveal reality for what it really is and it can help us chart the way forward to restore economic integrity and build a better Financial system system that is god- Centric that is seeing human with all four dimensions that is building the place that is better place for all of us that rewards the
things that should be rewarded and does not incentivize things that have harmful detrimental impact on the society thank you for spending time to watch this CashNews.co if you would like to learn more about text-decoration: none;">Finance and economy from Islamic perspective head to our new platform Muslim Money Matters where we go in much greater details regarding the content until next next time my name is Al chanam alikum
CashNews, your go-to portal for financial news and insights.
In this video, we provide a simple wisdom of Islamic finance, as seen in the most basic transaction like a home loan where the idea is to structure financing around the purchase and sale of a real asset, as opposed to a loan from a conventional bank that is divorced from the real economy at the core of the transaction. This is not a detailed explanation of the transaction's ins and outs per se, but rather to illustrate the principle and the wisdom behind it. In one of the future videos, we will, insha'Allah, explore the technical details of these transactions and how they work practically.
I've asked the same question. Im Christian and grew up amongst the most amazing people in district 6 including Muslims. I would prefer to put my money into Islamic banking instead of white people's banks, although i love them as well 🥰🥰🥰
please can u comment on @gary economics theory
Ok but how does MCCA have skin in the game. What sort of risks is the financier sharing?
First of all, thank you for explaining these videos very clearly and helping to improve our Islamic finance.
I want to ask some question.
First, does the Islamic bank use leverage? If they do, why, they lend money but they don't have enough money in the bank, how can they deal with it if all the clients withdraw their money?
Secondly, Islamic bank is trading with real assets as you said but they use inflation government but this rate is not real because many governments change this rate as they want, in the end this asset maybe will be more or less how will Islamic bank show this loss or gain.
Thirdly, the ordinary bank borrows money from customers, for example 3% per annum, they give money to the one who needs money, maybe more than 4%, the Islamic bank does the same thing as you know, is this 1% gain an operating expense for them or a gain?
The principle is that lender and borrower needs to share the risks and rewards. In home purchase transactions the lender does not take any risks. Any fall in house value is at the borrowers cost. There are no real Islamic products on the market so stick to renting.
I have a question about the point system whether in banks or other services like phone subscriptions where you collect points based on how much you spend over the years. Is using these points considered riba as you can argue cause it is a result of the product and incentive for it but in reality I think it’s about spend more money get better offers.
Perfect!
Thomas Susan Williams Jessica Lopez Margaret
This is probably why the West is secretly waging a war against Islam. I'm not religious, but when set with the context of the West World, it makes me scream Allahu Akbar! Islam is probably the last bastion of humanity against the matrix.
Beautiful video
First problem my friends is that Money (fiat) as know it is directly sourced from interest based Treasury Bills so I don't know how Muslims can incorporate this type of money with Islamic system. Secondly no banks are using funds from depots to acquire any assets for themselves or for their clients, all that money is being created out of this air… So what so different!!!
Anything not holding it's value cannot be used as money in Islam. Paper money is haram and the root cause of all financial problems. We must use paper money's value relative to gold in Islam.
Charging a fee, instead of interest, is nice. But there is no uniquness in it. It is the same thing named differently.
On a larger scale it translates to exactly the same too.
The christian banks used to have the same problem as muslim banks and they solved it with accepting interests, as part of seperating religion and state.
Renaming something doesn't mean you invented something new.
Islamic banks should buy the whole asset itself and then sell it to the buyer. All it does is financing for buyer with out taking any responsibility or loss at an exorbitant rate.
Selam alejkum brate almire baš si lijepo objasnio sa zadovoljstvom te slušam odavno kapitalizam si objasnio u bocu baš je tako kako si rekao..ali vezano je sa realnom ekonomijom samo kroz realnu imovinu u smislu da se dodatnim printanim novcem u sistemu stvara dodatna potražnja za realnim dobrima kao što su imobilije i zbog toga cijene rastu u nedogled. Danas npr u švicarskoj imamo intergeneracijske krrdite gdje npr otac krene isplaćivati Kredit za kuću ili stan a nakon decenija nastave kredit isplaćivati njegova djeca. To je ludilo.. klasični keynesianizam
Excellent explanation brother Almir!
Now I understand little from zero about Islamic Banking!
Nothing vague, nothing hard to understand just clear and very logical. Please share the video guys. BarakAllahu feekum brother Almir.
One of the fallacies presented in the clip is insisting that ( paper fiat currency ) is money. Claiming that this is Islam position re this matter is something that is doubtful and disputed to say the least.
Rethinking our economic system is to move away from fractional reserve. and removing fractional reserve is making bank only as custodians. therefore i think, rethinking our economic system is to get rid of banks or a system where banks can't loan money they don't have. if mr colan can rethink a new system unlike the fractional reserve but keep the money distribution possible, he would be truly "made it" 😀😀
Do you provide any islamic finance courses?
"The natural state of a REAL economy", I like this quote of yours. It could make a good book title on Islamic finance or lecture series.
And one thing to note is that with an Islamic finance/economic system, its a win win for ALL participants/stake holders.☘
Unfortunately most Islamic banks also use fractional reserve banking where they create money out of thin air for their operation which is also a form of riba. It seems like they are trying to fit in the modern banking system which is inherently not Islamic at all. Islamic banking is an oxymoron.
You cant fix banking without fixing the money creation which is riba based. Please stop misguiding people
Jazakallah khair brother
Assalamu Alaikum. Whats the position of Tax as a mean to generate revenue. Will it have the same effects as discussed in the video.
Everyone who has explained Islamic finance has only ever been able to use it for simple asset transactions. For more complex transactions I haven't got any workable system.
For example if I need some bridge financing to handle some contingencies for an ongoing business how would you calculate how much to pay back to the lender
Masha Allah
Subhanallah ❤
Banking is banking no matter what system you use. Other wise it is just a donation.
Sadly..muslim nation lead by hypocrite….aaaaaa
Before you talke on Islamic banking, you should first address whether use of paper money is Islamic or not.
Is islamic banks really islamic?
Islamic banking is very deceitful because the actual sale and purchase between the buyer and bank do not transpire. The transaction is only documented on paper, and the Islamic bank never truly possesses the asset it purports to sell. For genuine ownership, the Islamic bank must first acquire the asset from the seller.
In practice, the buyer pays a down payment to the seller for the asset, then approaches the Islamic bank for financing. After background checks, the bank approves the financing and pays the remaining balance to the seller. The buyer then takes possession of the asset from the seller. Since the Islamic bank never owns the asset, this process is deceptive and constitutes riba, which is warned against in Islam for those equating it with regular buying and selling transactions.
Furthermore, if the asset is damaged or broken, the Islamic bank does not assume the responsibility of a seller to provide a warranty or accept the return of the asset from the buyer. Instead, the Islamic bank will direct the buyer to resolve the issue with the seller directly. This serves as additional evidence that Islamic banks do not engage in buying and selling transactions; they merely facilitate financing for the buyer to acquire the asset from the seller.
احل الله البيع وحرم الربا
The above is the pilar of any human economy
Let them pass and let them work not let them finance and suck each other sweat and blood